Members
- Frank P. Weaver (Chief)
- Joseph A. Mallery
- Matthew W. Hill
- Charles T. Donworth
- Robert C. Finley
- Hugh J. Rosellini
- Richard B. Ott
- Harry Ellsworth Foster
- Robert T. Hunter
Notes
- Matthew W. Hill resigned Chief Justice on Monday, January 12th, 1959
- Frank P. Weaver elected Chief Justice on Monday, January 12th, 1959